The Top 3 Things You Didn't Know About Used Jewelry Stores

The Top 3 Things You Didn't Know About Used Jewelry Stores

In a world where fast fashion and mass production often take center stage, the allure of used jewelry offers a refreshing, meaningful alternative. Welcome to this comprehensive guide where we'll explore the ins and outs of buying used jewelry from reputable stores. The purpose of this blog post is to shed light on the numerous benefits of opting for used jewelry over new pieces, and to guide you through the process of making an informed purchase.

So, why should you consider buying used jewelry? First and foremost, it's an eco-friendly choice. By giving new life to pre-owned items, you're contributing to a more sustainable form of consumerism. Second, used jewelry often comes with a rich history and unique character that new pieces can't replicate. Whether it's a vintage engagement ring from the Art Deco era or an antique brooch that has seen centuries pass by, each piece tells a story. Third, used jewelry often provides better value for money. Unlike new items that depreciate the moment they leave the store, used pieces often retain or even appreciate in value over time, making them not just a fashion statement but also a potential investment.

In addition to these benefits, buying from a reputable used jewelry store ensures that you're getting authentic, high-quality items. Reputable stores offer certificates of authenticity, detailed appraisals, and even money-back guarantees, providing an extra layer of security and peace of mind.

In the sections that follow, we'll delve into the different types of used jewelry you can find, from vintage and antique to estate and pre-owned pieces. We'll offer tips on how to evaluate the quality, authenticity, and value of these items, including what to look for in terms of hallmarks, certificates, and appraisals. Finally, we'll recommend some reliable and trustworthy sources, both online and offline, where you can make your next dazzling purchase.

So, if you're ready to explore the fascinating world of used jewelry, read on. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a newbie looking to make your first purchase, this guide aims to equip you with the knowledge and confidence to find that perfect piece that speaks to you.

Types of Used Jewelry

When it comes to used jewelry, the variety is as vast as it is captivating. Each category offers its own unique charm, history, and value proposition. Understanding these different types can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your taste, lifestyle, and budget. Let's delve into the primary categories: vintage, antique, estate, and pre-owned jewelry.

Vintage Jewelry

The term "vintage" is often used to describe pieces that are at least 20 to 30 years old but less than 100 years old. Vintage jewelry captures the essence of bygone eras, from the geometric designs of the Art Deco period to the free-spirited flair of the '60s and '70s. These pieces often reflect the craftsmanship, materials, and artistic sensibilities of the time they were made, offering a tangible connection to the past. Vintage jewelry is especially popular among those who appreciate unique designs that stand out from contemporary styles.

This 2.15 carat 14K gold ring is an example of a vintage setting transformed into a modern Tiffany setting sold by a used jewelry store. The ‘bonus’ 14K yellow gold vintage setting even comes with 1.13 carats of baguettes.

Antique Jewelry

Antique jewelry is a step further back in time, referring to pieces that are at least 100 years old. This category can include anything from Victorian brooches adorned with intricate filigree work to Edwardian engagement rings with their classic elegance. Antique pieces are not just fashion statements; they are historical artifacts. They often feature craftsmanship techniques that are rare or even lost today, making them highly valuable both aesthetically and financially.

Estate Jewelry

The term "estate" is often used to describe any piece of jewelry that has been previously owned, regardless of its age. Estate jewelry can range from a two-year-old diamond necklace from a high-end brand to a 200-year-old family heirloom. The common thread is that these pieces have a history; they've been worn and loved before. This category offers a wide range of styles and price points, making it accessible to almost anyone interested in used jewelry.

Pre-Owned Jewelry

Pre-owned is a broad category that includes any jewelry that has had a previous owner. While this can overlap with estate jewelry, pre-owned often refers to more contemporary pieces. These items are generally less than 20 years old and can sometimes be almost indistinguishable from new jewelry. The primary advantage of buying pre-owned is the cost savings, as these pieces are often sold at a fraction of their original retail price.

Each of these categories has its own unique appeal:

  • Vintage for its artistic and period-specific designs
  • Antique for its historical significance and rare craftsmanship
  • Estate for its wide variety and potential for unique finds
  • Pre-Owned for its affordability and modern styles

Whether you're drawn to the romantic allure of an antique locket or the budget-friendly appeal of a pre-owned bracelet, the world of used jewelry offers something for everyone. In the next section, we'll discuss how to evaluate the quality, authenticity, and value of these fascinating pieces, so you can shop with confidence and find a treasure that truly resonates with you.

How to Choose Used Jewelry

Choosing used jewelry is an art form that combines a keen eye for detail, a bit of research, and a dash of intuition. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a first-time buyer, knowing how to evaluate the quality, authenticity, and value of used jewelry can make all the difference in your purchasing experience. Here are some essential tips to guide you through this exciting journey.

Check for Hallmarks

One of the first things to look for when evaluating a piece of used jewelry is the hallmark. A hallmark is a stamp or engraving on the jewelry that indicates the metal content, the maker, or sometimes even the date and place of manufacture. For example, "925" signifies sterling silver, while "750" indicates 18K gold. Hallmarks can provide valuable clues about the piece's origin and authenticity.

Ask for Certificates and Appraisals

When buying from a reputable used jewelry store, always ask for any available certificates or appraisals. A certificate of authenticity will confirm the metal and gemstone content, while an appraisal will provide an estimated value of the piece. These documents are particularly crucial for high-value items like diamond rings or antique heirlooms. They not only validate the item's worth but also serve as essential records for insurance purposes.

For instance, this designer 18K rose gold Tacori engagement ring set comes with a physical GIA certification to ensure its authenticity!

Examine the Craftsmanship

Quality craftsmanship is often a telltale sign of a valuable piece of jewelry. Pay close attention to the intricacy of the design, the neatness of the setting, and the quality of the gemstones. Are the stones securely set? Are there any signs of repair or alterations? High-quality craftsmanship will stand the test of time, making these pieces more likely to retain or even appreciate in value.

Consider the Condition

The condition of a used piece can significantly impact its value and longevity. Look for any signs of wear and tear, such as scratches, dents, or loose settings. While some age-related wear can add to the charm of vintage or antique pieces, excessive damage could be a red flag. Always factor in any potential repair costs when considering the overall value of the item.

Do Your Research

Before making a purchase, it's wise to do some background research on the specific type of jewelry you're interested in. Familiarize yourself with the typical characteristics, price ranges, and notable makers of that category. Whether it's a vintage Rolex watch or an Art Nouveau brooch, having a baseline knowledge will help you make a more informed decision.

Trust Your Instincts

Last but not least, trust your gut feeling. If a piece speaks to you, resonates with your style, and checks all the boxes for quality and authenticity, it's likely a good fit. After all, the most important factor in choosing a piece of jewelry is how it makes you feel.

By following these guidelines—checking for hallmarks, asking for certificates, examining craftsmanship, considering condition, doing your research, and trusting your instincts—you'll be well-equipped to find a piece of used jewelry that's not just a fashion statement but also a wise investment. In the next section, we'll explore where to buy these hidden gems, ensuring you're shopping from sources as reliable as your newfound knowledge.

Where to Buy Used Jewelry

Now that you're well-versed in the types of used jewelry and how to choose the right pieces, the next logical question is, "Where can I buy these treasures?" The good news is that there are numerous avenues, both online and offline, where you can find high-quality, authentic used jewelry. However, the key to a successful purchase lies in choosing a reliable and trustworthy source. Here are some recommendations to guide you in your quest.


Hand-Me-Diamonds is an online used jewelry store with dozens of pre-owned pieces looking for a home! With a presence on major marketplaces like Poshmark, Ebay, Etsy, and others, Hand-Me-Diamonds is here to help you get more diamond for your dollar.


Etsy is another online platform that specializes in unique and handmade items, including a large selection of vintage and antique jewelry. The site is user-friendly and often provides a detailed history and description of each piece. Like eBay, it's essential to check the seller's reputation and reviews. Many Etsy sellers are passionate about what they do and are more than willing to provide additional information and certificates upon request.

Pawn Shops

Pawn shops can be a goldmine for used jewelry at bargain prices. However, the quality and authenticity can vary significantly. If you're considering buying from a pawn shop, it's advisable to go in person so you can closely examine the piece. Always ask for any available documentation and consider getting an independent appraisal for high-value items.

Local Jewelers

Many local jewelry stores offer a selection of used or estate jewelry. The advantage of buying from a local jeweler is the ability to build a long-term relationship. These stores often provide services like cleaning, repair, and appraisals, adding an extra layer of security to your purchase. Plus, you can see and touch the jewelry in person, which is invaluable for assessing its quality and fit.

Auction Houses

For those interested in high-end antique or estate pieces, auction houses like Sotheby's or Christie's can be excellent sources. These establishments provide detailed catalogs and often hold viewings before the auction. While the prices can go high, you're likely to find some truly exceptional and rare pieces.

Online Specialty Stores

There are also online stores that specialize exclusively in used, vintage, or antique jewelry. These stores often provide comprehensive information, high-quality photos, and certificates of authenticity. Make sure to read their return and warranty policies to ensure a safe and satisfying purchase.

In summary, whether you're an online shopper or prefer the tactile experience of a physical store, there are plenty of reliable sources for buying used jewelry. The key is to do your due diligence—check seller reviews, ask for documentation, and when possible, examine the piece in person. Armed with the knowledge from this guide, you're well-equipped to find that perfect piece of used jewelry that speaks to your heart and complements your style. In the concluding section, we'll wrap up the main points and encourage you to take the next step in your jewelry journey.


As we wrap up this comprehensive guide on buying used jewelry, let's revisit the key points that make this option so compelling. First and foremost, opting for used jewelry is a sustainable choice that aligns with eco-friendly consumerism. It allows you to own a piece of history, be it a vintage ring that captures the essence of a bygone era or an antique brooch that serves as a historical artifact. Moreover, used jewelry often provides better value for your money, offering the chance for investment as well as aesthetic appeal.

We've explored the different categories of used jewelry—vintage, antique, estate, and pre-owned—each with its unique characteristics and allure. Whether you're drawn to the artistic designs of vintage pieces or the modern styles of pre-owned items, the world of used jewelry has something for everyone.

In terms of choosing the right piece, we discussed the importance of checking for hallmarks, asking for certificates and appraisals, examining the craftsmanship, and considering the condition. These steps are crucial for evaluating the quality, authenticity, and value of a piece, ensuring that you make an informed decision.

We also delved into various reliable and trustworthy sources where you can buy used jewelry. From online platforms like eBay and Etsy to physical stores like local jewelers and pawn shops, the options are plentiful. The key to a successful purchase is doing your due diligence—researching the seller, asking for documentation, and when possible, examining the piece in person.

So, what's stopping you from exploring this fascinating world? With the knowledge and tips provided in this guide, you're well-equipped to make a purchase that's not just a fashion statement but also a wise investment. Whether you're a seasoned collector or a first-time buyer, the realm of used jewelry offers endless possibilities to discover pieces that resonate with your style, history, and values. So go ahead, take the plunge and find that unique, meaningful piece that's been waiting just for you. Happy treasure hunting!

Back to blog